Editor’s Note: This week, despite the increasingly grim outlook for the U.S. auto manufacturers, Peter insists once again that the True Believers still offer the best hope for at least a fighting chance at survival. In On The Table, we take a look at a new addition to the VW GTI family. Our video this week features “The Making of Grand Prix, Part I” (still the greatest racing movie ever made, according to PMD). Our AE Song of the Week is “Everybody Wants To Rule The World” by Tears For Fears. In Fumes, Peter presents Part VI of his series, “The Racers.” And finally, in The Line, we have F1 results from Las Vegas and MotoGP from Portugal. We also have a retrospective on the Porsche 804, the machine that delivered Porsche’s only win in F1 (as a constructor), thanks to Dan Gurney. Remember, you can read past issues by scrolling down and clicking on “Next 1 Entries.” Happy Thanksgiving! -WG
By Peter M. DeLorenzo
Detroit. Though I’m tired of using the term “swirling maelstrom” to describe this business, I have yet to find a more apt descriptor. It’s a land where you’re only as good as your last hit, a state of mind where you’re forced to make what’s happening right now work, while struggling to make what’s happening next come into focus. It’s a cruel, nonsensical world that punishes those who would deign to march to a different drummer, but it’s only those who dare to break through that gauntlet who rise to the top.
It’s easy to get mired in the minutiae of this business – the endless meetings, the constant “reviews,” the endless hand-wringing and second (and third) guessing. Overthinking might be an operational component in corporate America, but in the automobile business it’s a full-blown cottage industry, which makes effectual decisions extremely hard to come by. Why? Because 90 percent of the time is spent worrying about what an upper executive in question might want or might be thinking, which forces underlings to become interpreters and acquire the skill set of nuanced anticipation.
This business is unfortunately littered with so-called genius executives who parachute into the decision process, make a few pronouncements, then helicopter out. And the worst part of this phenomenon is that they come back six weeks later and question why a particular direction was undertaken, totally forgetting that’s what he or she directed. Thus, time, effort and money are wasted at a prodigious rate because executives are too self-absorbed to get their heads out of their asses and realize how destructive their behavior is. And no, this isn’t exclusive to the automobile business, but it’s decidedly more pathetic when product programs or advertising campaigns are on the line.
Ah, yes, product. Product is the straw that stirs the drink, the raison d’etre of the automobile business. It’s not selling air. It’s not about what a company’s vision of down the road will be. That’s all well and good and fine and wonderful, but it’s not the business now and it isn’t the business for the next 36 months. It’s about product cadence, which means having the right products, at the right time, for the right market segments. Whatever a company’s vision is for the future doesn’t matter if it isn’t generating serious profits to fund that future.
Remarkably enough, some companies forget all of this. They get sidetracked and off kilter, they chase their tails, they start listening to the dulcet tones of their own thought balloons, and they become buried under the heavy mantel of their own hubris. In short, they lose their way and start making mistakes. Except this isn’t a business that tolerates mistakes. It’s not a strike three enterprise, either. Two strikes and you’re out. And in this league, playing catchup is not only a brutally tough and long road – sometimes it just doesn’t work out. And in the new reality of this globally-driven automobile business, some car companies are just not going to make it.
Ford, GM and Stellantis are facing consequential hard truths right now. They’re dancing in order to balance ICE demand with Hybrids and EVs. And it’s a constantly changing playing field. Collectively, they have already ceded the global market to China, Inc. And this just in: It’s never coming back. So, they’re faced with surviving here, which is rapidly becoming a closed market to anything other than pickups, gigantic SUVs and an endless series of uninspired crossovers. Oh, sure, we’ll have Farley’s unfathomable “wonder truck” to paw over by the end of next year (allegedly), and GM is promising a slew of Hybrids sometime, well, whenever. And Stellantis will keep feeding its muscle-head machine until there’s nowhere left to turn. But the harsh reality for the U.S. automakers is that they’re racing headlong toward The Abyss, and the predictions aren’t good for their long-term health, or survival.
I do know one thing for certain, however. The companies stocked with True Believers, the ones unafraid to dream, the ones focused on delivering the best in all aspects of this business – Design, Engineering, Product Development, Marketing – will at least have a fighting chance. It not only requires savvy management, it requires a complete cessation of the normal bureaucratic cesspool that paralyzes these companies, which means loosening the reins on the True Believers so that they can do what they’re capable of doing.
When it comes to The Future of this business for the domestic automakers, it’s still grim. But I will continue to bet on the companies who value their True Believers, because those companies who refuse to do so will be ringing their death knells much sooner.
And that’s the High-Octane Truth for this week.
Have a nice Thanksgiving, everyone.
Editor’s Note: You can access previous issues of AE by clicking on “Next 1 Entries” below. – WG